I used up all these mascaras: which ones were a hit and which ones a miss?

I have used these 6 mascaras and I will tell you which ones were a hit and which ones a miss!

1. Wander Beauty Mile High Club Mascara // Sephora 

I always wanted to belong to the Mile High Club 😂 and now I do! But seriously: this mascara creates the longest lashes possible! I need a new tube of this lengthening magic mascara for sure! Absolutely love it! 😍

2. Rimmel Wonder'Extension Mascara // Amazon

You can definitely not use this as a stand-alone mascara- because it clumps a bunch. If you use first a different mascara and then apply this mascara on the tips of your lashes, it can lengthen your lashes, because little fiber pieces will stick to your lashes and elongate your own lashes. However, one day I applied this mascara and one of the fibers landed a couple of hours later inside my eyeballs (which hurt a lot!) and I am scared to apply this mascara ever again. Will not be using this again because of this.

3. Makeup Revolution 5D Lash Mascara // Ulta

With a name like this I had high hopes. Unfortunately the mascara did not deliver. It does nothing. Neither lengthen nor giving volume. This one is a miss.

4. Urban Decay Cosmetics Lash Freak Volumizing & Lengthening Mascara // Ulta

THIS ONE! has got to be the WORST mascara I have ever tried! The weird silicone wand that looks like a comb and does absolutely nothing! If you like undefined messy clumpy lashes then you will love this. 😈

5. Urban Decay Cosmetics Size Perversion Mascara // Ulta

Somehow the wand is too big for my tiny eyes and so I always manage to have little accidents smudging mascara onto my eyelids that I have to wipe away. After a couple of hours I also tend to get raccoon eyes with this mascara. 🐼A miss!

6. Anastasia Beverly Hills Lash Brag Volumizing Mascara // Ulta

This has got to be the tiniest mascara sample in the world- however, I was pleasantly surprised by how much I liked it! It reminds me very much on my all time favorite mascara: Too Faced Better than Sex Mascara. The wand has a similar hourglass shape and it gives me volume AND length! I really like it and it is $2 cheaper than my old-time fave! 😁

There you have it! What is your favorite mascara?

Disclaimer: Contains Affiliate links. Read my full disclosure.